Betty

1. This clue might take you back to a more innocent age. Or not.

2. Look at the keys with the numbers mentioned. They have something in common.

3. At least the first five do. 9 is only sometimes considered to be one of them.

4. Ignore the numbers and focus on the letters of these keys.

5. Specifically one letter per key.

6. Five letters, sometimes six, that have something in common.

7. Or, as some of us learned in grade school, A-E-I-O-U and sometimes Y.

(SOLUTION FOLLOWS)

↓

8. They're vowels. Type VOWELS (869357).